Homemade marshmallows
CostFree to Low
Includes: Gelatine, sugar and glucose per batch Example: 3-5 per batch of around 50 marshmallows
What it is
The mixer is running, a thin stream of hot sugar syrup is trickling in, and over a few minutes a clear glossy liquid swells into a thick white cloud that climbs the bowl. That moment of watching marshmallow appear from almost nothing is why people who make them once rarely stop.
Homemade marshmallows are the practice of whipping a hot sugar syrup into bloomed gelatine until it transforms into a light, airy, set foam. The result bears little resemblance to the dense, slightly rubbery bagged version. Fresh marshmallow is soft, fluffy, and tender, with a clean flavour you can scent however you like, from vanilla to coffee to rose.
The science is a balance of three things: a sugar syrup cooked to around 115°C, gelatine softened in cold water, and air whipped in by a stand mixer. The hot syrup dissolves and activates the gelatine, and the long whipping incorporates the air that gives marshmallow its volume. As it cools, the gelatine sets the foam into a sliceable slab, which you cut and dust with a mix of icing sugar and cornflour to stop it sticking.
Most people start with a simple vanilla batch and are surprised it needs no special equipment beyond a stand mixer and a thermometer. The honest trade-off is that the hot syrup is genuinely dangerous and the mixture is relentlessly sticky, so it is not a tidy process. But a tray costs a fraction of artisan marshmallows and tastes incomparably better.
How it works
Most first attempts fail because people lose their nerve with the hot syrup and stop short of temperature, leaving marshmallows that never set. The syrup must reach the firm-ball stage, 115 to 120°C, and a thermometer is the only way to know. Below this they stay as sticky goo; this is the most common cause of failure.
Bloom the gelatine first by sprinkling it over cold water and letting it swell into a soft sponge. Meanwhile cook sugar, water, and glucose syrup or golden syrup to that firm-ball temperature. A stand mixer is close to essential here, because the next step needs sustained high-speed whipping that exhausts a hand whisk.
With the mixer running on medium, pour the hot syrup down the side of the bowl in a thin steady stream onto the bloomed gelatine, avoiding the moving whisk so it does not fling molten sugar. Then crank to high and whip. Over the next five to ten minutes the clear mixture triples in volume and turns thick, white, and glossy, holding a thick ribbon when the whisk lifts.
Add vanilla or other flavouring near the end, then scrape into a tin dusted generously with a cornflour and icing sugar mix, which stops it sticking. Leave it uncovered several hours to set before cutting with an oiled knife.
Benefits
What you need
Here's what to gather before you start. The essentials are marked.
Some links below are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, trylii.com earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
FAQs
A stand mixer makes it vastly easier, and I'd hesitate to do it with a handheld. The mixture whips for a solid 10-12 minutes at high speed, which is exhausting and risky to do by hand while also dealing with hot syrup. A handheld can technically work if you have someone helping, but the stand mixer frees both hands for pouring the syrup. It's the one piece of kit I'd insist on.
Soft-ball stage, around 115-118°C. This is lower than candy or brittle, and hitting it matters, because too low gives runny marshmallows that won't set and too high makes them tough and chewy. Use a thermometer and watch it closely near the end, since the last few degrees come quickly. Pour the syrup into the whipping gelatine in a slow, steady stream down the side of the bowl.
Usually under-whipped or under-cooked syrup. The mixture needs to whip until it's thick, glossy, and tripled in volume, holding a ribbon when you lift the whisk, which takes longer than people expect. If the syrup didn't reach temperature, no amount of whipping will set them properly. Weeping also happens in humid weather, so I dust them well with the cornflour-icing sugar mix and store them airtight.
Equal parts cornflour and icing sugar. This coating stops the sticky marshmallows clinging to each other and to your hands, and you dust the tin, the cut surfaces, and the finished pieces with it. Without it, they fuse into one sticky block. I keep a bowl of it handy and dust my knife between cuts too.
Easily, and that's half the fun. Add flavour extracts or a swirl of fruit purée when the mixture is nearly whipped, and gel colour (not liquid) at the same stage. Vanilla is classic, but peppermint, rose, coffee, and toasted versions all work. For swirls, drizzle colour over the poured mixture and drag a skewer through before it sets.